In what is a long-awaited judgement, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has stopped short of ruling conclusively as to whether Article 56A of the Malta Gaming Act is applicable with EU laws.
The court stated that the case made by the Austrian court for a preliminary ruling was ‘inadmissible’.
The case originates from Austrian players seeking to recover losses from Maltese-licensed casinos that are unlicensed in Austria. The conflict has taken on multiple junctures and extends beyond Austrian boundaries in October 2024, Vienna’s Commercial Court lodged a request for a ruling to be determined by the CJEU.
Austrian courts had ruled that the fund be repaid to the players. However, as documented, in June 2023, Malta amended its Gaming Act via the amendment of Article 56A to deny actions brought against gaming operators holding a Maltese licence by foreign courts.
The amendment of Article 56A (commonly referred to as Bill 55) was deemed as Malta’s direct defence of online gambling licences granted by the Malta Gambling Authority (MGA) against enforcement and penalties sanctioned by other EU member states.
As opposed to disregarding CJEU rules, Malta cites that its courts were applying public policy exceptions under the Brussels I Recast Regulation (EU) 1215/2012, reinforced domestically by Article 56A, to block the enforcement of foreign civil decisions that they argue undermine Malta’s gaming regulatory framework.
However, the CJEU has essentially declined to rule on the validity of Article 56A, whilst not a defining decision, it is a weakening for Malta’s reliance on Article 56A when it comes to the rulings of foreign courts, with the case likely to return to the Vienna Commercial Court.
As such, the substantive question of compatibility with EU law remains unresolved, with the underlying dispute set to return to the Commercial Court of Vienna, where claimant Spielerschutz Sigma is pursuing a damages claim against its former legal advisor.
The judgment nevertheless comes amid continued scrutiny of Malta’s legislation, following a strongly worded opinion from Advocate General Nicholas Emiliou in April.
He stated that the preliminary reference on the bill was inadmissible and not necessary for the conclusion of a case before the Austrian courts. Emiliou accelerated a trend across Europe that will intensify pressure on Malta, as he remained unrelenting in his criticism of Bill 55, describing it as ‘manifestly incompatible with the rules governing the recognition and enforcement of judgments’ by Brussels.
Although the CJEU has not adopted that assessment, the Advocate General’s opinion clearly indicates the legal objections facing Malta’s approach as the wider dispute over the enforcement of foreign gambling judgments continues.
Don’t forget to subscribe to our Telegram channel!






